The correct answer is that Carrie is ONE and Rusty is TWO. We could possibly explain how we arrived at that (we haven't tried yet), but if someone wants to comment on how you arrived at your answer, that's something that could be fun to read as a comment.
The three people who guessed correctly receive these photo-crowns.
The two people who guessed incorrectly are also winners just for playing, but they get loving dunce caps.
Thanks for playing, and Happy Halloween!